Año | Jugador | Posición | Equipo | Draft | Universidad |
1996 | Steve Ralston | Centrocampista | Tampa Bay Mutiny | College Draft de la MLS 1996 | Florida International |
1997 | Mike Duhaney | Defensa | Tampa Bay Mutiny | Draft Inaugural de la MLS 1996 | UNLV |
1998 | Ben Olsen | Centrocampista | D.C. United | Project-40 | Virginia |
1999 | Jay Heaps | Defensa | Miami Fusion | College Draft de la MLS 1999 | Duke |
2000 | Carlos Bocanegra | Defensa | Chicago Fire | SuperDraft de la MLS 2000 | UCLA |
2001 | Rodrigo Faria | Delantero | MetroStars | SuperDraft de la MLS 2001 | Concordia College |
2002 | Kyle Martino | Centrocampista | Columbus Crew | SuperDraft de la MLS 2002 | Virginia |
2003 | Damani Ralph | Delantero | Chicago Fire | SuperDraft de la MLS 2003 | Connecticut |
2004 | Clint Dempsey | Centrocampista | New England Revolution | SuperDraft de la MLS 2004 | Furman |
2005 | Michael Parkhurst | Defensa | New England Revolution | SuperDraft de la MLS 2005 | Wake Forest |
2006 | Jonathan Bornstein | Defensa | Chivas USA | SuperDraft de la MLS 2006 | UCLA |
2007 | Maurice Edu | Centrocampista | Toronto FC | SuperDraft de la MLS 2007 | Maryland |
2008 | Sean Franklin | Defensa | LA Galaxy | SuperDraft de la MLS 2008 | Cal State Northridge |
2009 | Omar Gonzalez | Defensa | LA Galaxy | SuperDraft de la MLS 2009 | Maryland |
2010 | Andy Najar | Centrocampista | D.C. United | SuperDraft de la MLS 2010 | N/A |
2011 | C. J. Sapong | Delantero | Sporting Kansas City | SuperDraft de la MLS 2011 | James Madison |
2012 | Austin Berry | Defensa | Chicago Fire | SuperDraft de la MLS 2012 | Louisville |
2013 | Dillon Powers | Centrocampista | Colorado Rapids | SuperDraft de la MLS 2013 | Notre Dame |
2014 | Tesho Akindele | Delantero | FC Dallas | SuperDraft de la MLS 2014 | Colorado School of Mines |
2015 | Cyle Larin | Delantero | Orlando City SC | SuperDraft de la MLS 2015 | Connecticut |
2016 | Jordan Morris | Delantero | Seattle Sounders FC | Jugador de cantera | Stanford |
2017 | Julian Gressel | Centrocampista | Atlanta United | SuperDraft de la MLS 2017 | Providence College |
2018 | Corey Baird | Delantero | Real Salt Lake | Jugador de cantera | Stanford |
2019 | Andre Shinyashiki | Delantero | Colorado Rapids | SuperDraft de la MLS 2019 | Denver |